A Reddit post has ignited a fiery online debate about carry-on luggage etiquette after a passenger recounted their experience with an oversized bag in the overhead bin. The original poster (OP) described a scenario where a fellow passenger placed their rolling carry-on sideways in the bin, effectively taking up two spots. This action prompted the OP to attempt to rearrange the bag to accommodate another passenger’s luggage.
The situation escalated when the owner of the oversized bag returned, claiming they hadn’t placed it sideways. A flight attendant intervened, informing the woman that her bag would need to be checked if it didn’t fit properly. Despite this, the woman insisted on placing the bag sideways again, leading to the OP’s frustration and subsequent Reddit post. The OP argued that a bag is too large to be considered a carry-on if it can’t fit in the overhead bin wheels-first. They also defended their decision to move the bag, stating they were helping an elderly passenger who couldn’t lift her own bag.
:max_bytes(150000):strip_icc():focal(870×679:872×681)/suitcases-overhead-bin-1725-38e6a26218f247afb673877511932e80.jpg)
The post generated a wide range of responses, with some Redditors supporting the OP’s actions and others criticizing them. Several commenters pointed out that not all airplanes have overhead bins designed for perpendicular loading. Some even shared experiences from international flights where airlines specifically instructed passengers to place bags sideways in certain bins.
However, many users agreed with the OP’s frustration regarding oversized carry-ons. They argued that these bags often lead to delays and force passengers with appropriately sized luggage to gate-check their belongings. Several people expressed annoyance that the flight attendant reprimanded the OP instead of addressing the passenger with the oversized bag. The discussion highlighted the common frustrations travelers face with limited overhead bin space and the lack of consistent enforcement of airline luggage policies.
:max_bytes(150000):strip_icc():focal(967×720:969×722)/large-suitcase-overhead-bin-1725-01670a0c66574ce8990c38a8538423d9.jpg)
The incident also brought to light differing opinions on touching other passengers’ belongings. While the OP felt justified in their attempt to help, others argued that it’s never appropriate to move someone else’s bag without permission. Experts, like Miami-based flight attendant Trey Antwan, advise against forcing oversized bags into overhead bins as it can cause delays. Antwan also recommends seeking permission before moving another passenger’s luggage to avoid potential conflicts.
:max_bytes(150000):strip_icc():focal(749×0:751×2)/stand-when-plane-lands-tout-3-031524-5a6f6aeafb1d46d7993b9f10d657ebbe.jpg)
Travel expert Nicole Campoy Jackson emphasizes the importance of involving flight attendants in such situations. She notes that flight attendants have more information and authority to resolve these issues effectively. This incident serves as a reminder of the ongoing challenges surrounding carry-on luggage and the importance of adhering to airline guidelines to ensure a smooth travel experience for everyone. The debate continues as passengers navigate the complexities of overhead bin etiquette and the frustration of limited space.
