The Miami Dolphins entered the 2023 NFL season with high expectations after a surprising playoff appearance the year prior. However, despite finishing the regular season with an 11-6 record, their playoff run was short-lived. A disappointing Wild Card loss to the Kansas City Chiefs left fans and analysts questioning the team’s direction. Now, the Dolphins face a pivotal offseason filled with difficult decisions.
Success Against Weaker Opponents, Struggles Against Contenders
One of the most glaring issues for the Dolphins in 2023 was their inconsistency against quality opponents. While they dominated weaker teams, they struggled mightily against playoff-caliber competition. This trend was particularly evident in the latter half of the season.
Miami Dolphins wide receiver Tyreek Hill runs with the ball during a game against the Buffalo Bills.
Their Week 18 loss to the Buffalo Bills, a game with significant playoff implications, exposed their vulnerabilities. The Bills, with a dominant rushing attack and a suffocating defense, controlled the game from start to finish. The Dolphins’ offense, despite boasting weapons like Tyreek Hill and Jaylen Waddle, looked outmatched.
Question Marks at Quarterback
The most significant question mark for the Dolphins this offseason revolves around quarterback Tua Tagovailoa. While Tua led the league in passing yards and finished fifth in touchdowns, his performance against top teams, coupled with his injury history, has sparked debate about his long-term viability as a franchise quarterback.
Miami Dolphins quarterback Tua Tagovailoa attempts a pass during a game.
Tagovailoa’s limitations were particularly evident in the playoff loss to the Chiefs. His lack of elite arm strength and limited mobility hindered the Dolphins’ offensive flexibility. The Chiefs, with their aggressive pass rush and complex defensive schemes, forced Tua into quick decisions and limited his effectiveness.
Tough Decisions Loom for the Dolphins’ Front Office
The Dolphins face a difficult decision regarding Tua’s contract situation. Entering the final year of his rookie deal, Tagovailoa’s next contract will likely command a significant financial commitment. However, his inconsistent play and injury history make such a commitment a risky proposition.
Beyond the quarterback position, the Dolphins must also address concerns on the defensive side of the ball. Injuries to key players, including Jaylen Phillips and Bradley Chubb, exposed their lack of depth, particularly in the pass rush. The Dolphins’ defense struggled to generate consistent pressure on opposing quarterbacks, especially in crucial late-game situations.
Navigating a Competitive AFC Landscape
The Miami Dolphins’ path forward is fraught with challenges. The AFC is loaded with talented teams, and the margin for error is slim. The Dolphins must make shrewd decisions in free agency and the draft to address their roster deficiencies and build a team capable of competing for a Super Bowl.
Miami Dolphins head coach Mike McDaniel watches from the sideline during a game.
Head Coach Mike McDaniel, now entering his third year, faces mounting pressure to deliver results. The honeymoon period is over, and the Dolphins’ front office and fan base alike expect to see tangible progress.
The 2024 offseason will be a defining one for the Miami Dolphins. Their ability to address their weaknesses and make tough decisions will determine whether they can take the next step and become a legitimate contender in the AFC.
