Grading 4 Big NFL Free Agent Signings One Year Later

The NFL offseason marks a period of strategic roster improvements for teams aiming to bounce back and secure a coveted playoff spot. Free agency becomes a battleground where teams invest significant capital, hoping to land that one missing piece that could propel them towards Super Bowl contention.

This article revisits four notable free agent signings from the previous year, evaluating their performance in the 2023 season. We’ll analyze the impact of these signings, examining their contributions and whether they lived up to the expectations set forth. Let’s delve into the world of free agency and assess the outcomes of these high-stakes acquisitions.

Jimmy Garoppolo’s Disappointing Stint with the Raiders

The Las Vegas Raiders made a significant move by signing quarterback Jimmy Garoppolo to a three-year, $72 million contract, with $45 million guaranteed. The hope was that Garoppolo would lead the team back to the playoffs after a disappointing 6-11 finish in 2022.

Jimmy Garoppolo in a Raiders Uniform

However, Garoppolo’s performance fell short of expectations. The Raiders’ offense struggled, finishing 23rd in points per game, averaging nearly four fewer points than the previous season with Derek Carr at the helm. Garoppolo’s tenure as the starter was short-lived, as he was benched mid-season in favor of rookie Aidan O’Connell.

Several factors contributed to Garoppolo’s struggles. His accuracy was inconsistent, and he threw at least one interception in every game he started. The offensive line also faced challenges in protecting him, resulting in a career-high 49 pressures allowed.

The Raiders’ decision to sign Garoppolo to a lucrative contract with guaranteed money backfired. The team is now in a difficult position, as releasing him would result in a significant salary cap hit.

Jesse Bates III Shines as a Bright Spot for the Falcons

Safety Jesse Bates III’s arrival in Atlanta generated considerable excitement among Falcons fans. The former Cincinnati Bengal inked a four-year, $64 million deal with $36 million guaranteed, tasked with bolstering a defense that ranked among the league’s worst in passing yards allowed in 2022.

Bates III’s impact was immediate and undeniable. He emerged as a true ballhawk in the Falcons’ secondary, leading the team with six interceptions, a third of Atlanta’s season total. He consistently made impact plays, showcasing his range, instincts, and ball skills.

Jesse Bates III Intercepting a Pass

Bates III’s performance went beyond interceptions. He was a force multiplier, solidifying the Falcons’ secondary and making those around him better. His presence allowed his teammates to play with more confidence, knowing they had a reliable last line of defense.

While the Falcons had a challenging season, finishing with a 7-10 record, Bates III’s performance provided a glimmer of hope. He proved to be a valuable addition and a cornerstone of their defense moving forward.

Mike McGlinchey’s Pricey Gamble with the Broncos

The Denver Broncos made a significant investment in right tackle Mike McGlinchey, signing him to a five-year, $87.5 million contract, with $52.5 million guaranteed. The move aimed to fortify an offensive line that struggled in 2022.

McGlinchey’s performance was a mixed bag. He brought a physical presence to the Broncos’ offensive line and showed flashes of his potential. However, he also struggled with consistency, particularly in pass protection, surrendering a career-high 49 pressures on the season.

Mike McGlinchey in a 49ers Uniform

It’s worth noting that playing alongside quarterback Russell Wilson, known for his tendency to extend plays and hold onto the ball, can pose challenges for offensive linemen. Wilson’s playing style often leads to increased pressure and sacks.

Despite the Broncos’ struggles and Wilson’s unpredictable nature, McGlinchey’s performance raised questions about whether his contract was justified.

Derek Carr’s Inconsistent Season with the Saints

The New Orleans Saints took a chance on quarterback Derek Carr, signing him to a four-year, $150 million deal with the hope that he could lead them back to the playoffs after a disappointing 2022 season.

Carr’s performance was inconsistent. He showed flashes of his talent, particularly in the latter part of the season, where the Saints finished strong. However, he also had his share of struggles, throwing for 2,880 yards, 13 touchdowns, and seven interceptions in the first 13 games.

Derek Carr Passing the Ball

While Carr put up respectable numbers in the final stretch of the season, his overall performance left Saints fans with more questions than answers. The Saints finished with a winning record but missed the playoffs, falling short of the expectations set forth when they signed Carr.

Final Thoughts

One year later, the success of these free agent signings is debatable. Jesse Bates III stood out as a home run acquisition, while the jury is still out on Mike McGlinchey and Derek Carr. Ultimately, the true impact of these signings will unfold in the seasons to come.