The rock world mourned the loss of guitar icon Eddie Van Halen in 2020. In the wake of his passing, whispers of a Van Halen tribute tour began to circulate, offering a glimmer of hope for fans eager to celebrate the band’s legacy. However, these hopes were ultimately dashed. In a revealing interview with Rolling Stone, Alex Van Halen, Eddie’s brother and the band’s drummer, finally shed light on the behind-the-scenes drama that led to the tour’s demise, placing the blame squarely on the shoulders of former frontman David Lee Roth.
David Lee Roth’s Refusal to Acknowledge Eddie Van Halen
The proposed tribute tour, initially rumored in 2022, was set to feature an impressive lineup, including Alex Van Halen, former Metallica bassist Jason Newsted, and guitar virtuoso Joe Satriani, who would take on the daunting task of filling Eddie’s shoes. Even original Van Halen bassist Michael Anthony was reportedly considered for the reunion. However, the project ultimately unraveled due to a fundamental disagreement between Alex and Roth.
Alex revealed that he had envisioned a poignant tribute to his late brother during each performance, perhaps incorporating archival footage, similar to how Queen honors Freddie Mercury. This seemingly reasonable request, however, sparked a furious reaction from Roth. “The moment I said we gotta acknowledge Ed,” Alex recounted, “Dave fuckin’ popped a fuse. … The vitriol that came out was unbelievable.”
The Fallout and Alex Van Halen’s Perspective
Alex, known for his straightforward demeanor, didn’t mince words when describing his reaction to Roth’s outburst. “I’m from the street,” he stated. “‘You talk to me like that, motherfucker, I’m gonna beat your fucking brains out. You got it?’ And I mean that. And that’s how it ended.” While he confirmed that he still maintains contact with Roth, the incident left him deeply disillusioned. “It’s just, my God. It’s like I didn’t know him anymore,” he lamented. He further emphasized the importance of collaboration, stating, “It’s not you alone anymore.”
Alex Van Halen’s Spinal Injury and Reflections on the Tribute
As fate would have it, the tribute tour might have been impossible even without the conflict with Roth. In 2022, Alex suffered a debilitating spinal injury during a trip to a shooting range. “The rifle kicked me on my ass,” he explained, “and broke my back, instantly. And then I spent a year on the floor. Just staring at the ceiling.” This injury severely limited his mobility, making drumming, let alone touring, out of the question.
Reflecting on the series of events, Alex expressed a sense of acceptance. “It’s too bad on one hand, but it’s fine on the other,” he mused. He questioned the true value of a tribute that simply rehashes old songs without the original creative force behind them. “Playing the old songs is not really paying tribute to anybody,” he argued. “That’s just like a jukebox, in my opinion. … To find a replacement for Ed? It’s just not the same.”
“Brothers”: A Memoir Celebrating Eddie Van Halen’s Legacy
Despite the setbacks and disappointments, Alex has found a way to honor his brother’s memory through his memoir, Brothers, released in October 2023. Described as a “love letter” to Eddie, the book delves into their unique relationship, both personal and musical. The audio version even includes previously unreleased music from the brothers, offering a rare glimpse into their creative process. In the book, Alex unequivocally states his view on the definitive Van Halen lineup: “The heart and the soul and the creativity and the magic was Dave, Ed, Mike and me.”
Van Halen’s Evolving Lineup Through the Years
The Van Halen brothers remained the constant core of the band throughout its history, while the roles of singer and bassist saw several changes. Over the years, three different singers and two different bassists joined the Van Halen brothers, contributing to the band’s evolving sound and dynamic. While David Lee Roth’s flamboyant stage presence and Michael Anthony’s solid bass lines defined the classic Van Halen era, subsequent lineups with Sammy Hagar and Gary Cherone on vocals, and Wolfgang Van Halen on bass, explored different musical territories. Each iteration of the band left its mark on rock history, but the core of the Van Halen legacy undeniably rests on the bond and creative synergy between Eddie and Alex.
Conclusion: A Tribute Lost, a Legacy Preserved
The unrealized Van Halen tribute tour remains a bittersweet chapter in the band’s history. While fans were undoubtedly disappointed by its cancellation, the circumstances surrounding it offer a deeper understanding of the complex dynamics within the band. David Lee Roth’s apparent reluctance to fully acknowledge Eddie’s contributions, coupled with Alex Van Halen’s health challenges, ultimately sealed the tour’s fate. However, Alex’s memoir, Brothers, stands as a testament to the enduring bond between the Van Halen brothers and a celebration of Eddie’s unparalleled musical genius.
Do you have any questions about the Van Halen tribute tour that never happened? Share your thoughts and questions in the comments below.
FAQ: Frequently Asked Questions about the Van Halen Tribute Tour
Q: Who was supposed to be in the Van Halen tribute band?
A: The proposed lineup included Alex Van Halen on drums, Joe Satriani on guitar, Jason Newsted on bass, and potentially Michael Anthony on bass as well.
Q: Why didn’t the Van Halen tribute tour happen?
A: The tour was cancelled primarily due to a disagreement between Alex Van Halen and David Lee Roth over how to acknowledge Eddie Van Halen during the shows. Alex’s spinal injury further complicated matters.
Q: Is there any chance the tribute tour could still happen in the future?
A: Given the circumstances, it seems highly unlikely that the tribute tour will ever materialize.
Q: Where can I learn more about the Van Halen brothers’ relationship?
A: Alex Van Halen’s memoir, Brothers, offers a detailed account of his relationship with Eddie.
We encourage you to share this article and participate in the discussion. What are your thoughts on the cancelled tribute tour and the future of the Van Halen legacy?
