A Gentleman’s Guide to Love and Murder captivated audiences and critics alike, winning the 2014 Tony Award for Best Musical. This uproarious musical comedy follows the ambitious Monty Navarro as he navigates a complex family tree and a series of unfortunate “accidents” on his quest for an earldom. This review delves into the witty plot, memorable characters, and ingenious staging that make this production a must-see.
From Rags to Riches (and a Few Murders Along the Way)
The story centers around Monty Navarro, a young man informed of his surprising lineage – he is ninth in line to become the Earl of Highhurst. Motivated by this revelation and a desire to escape poverty, Monty embarks on a darkly comedic journey, eliminating the eight D’Ysquith heirs who stand between him and the coveted title. The audience is privy to Monty’s internal struggles as he grapples with the morality of his actions while simultaneously rooting for his success.
A Love Triangle and a Cast of Unforgettable Characters
Adding another layer of complexity to the plot is a captivating love triangle. Monty is torn between Sibella Hallward, a beautiful but shallow social climber, and Phoebe D’Ysquith, a kind and intelligent woman who happens to be related to one of the unfortunate heirs. This romantic entanglement adds both humor and drama to the already engaging storyline. One of the production’s highlights is a cleverly staged scene where Monty frantically juggles his affections for both women, narrowly avoiding discovery.
alt: Monty Navarro juggling his relationships with Sibella and Phoebe in A Gentleman's Guide to Murder
One actor truly steals the show: Jefferson Mays, who plays all eight D’Ysquith heirs, each with distinct personalities and quirks. Mays’ versatility and comedic timing are impeccable, bringing a unique and hilarious dimension to the production. His performance alone makes the show worth watching.
Ingenious Staging and Memorable Music
The staging of A Gentleman’s Guide is as clever and inventive as the plot itself. The use of a stage within a stage adds depth and allows for creative transitions and visual gags. The death scenes are particularly noteworthy, each one uniquely staged and surprisingly humorous. The ice skating and church scenes are standouts, showcasing the production’s imaginative approach to storytelling.
The music, while perhaps not instantly memorable, complements the story well. Songs like “Why Are All the D’Ysquiths Dying?” capture the dark humor of the plot. While some of the lyrics, particularly those sung by Phoebe with her operatic voice, can be challenging to understand, they add to the overall charm and theatricality of the performance.
Is it Suitable for Younger Audiences?
The question of the show’s appropriateness for children is complex. While the humor and clever staging can be appreciated by older children, the themes of adultery and murder might be too mature for younger audiences. The lack of graphic violence and sexual explicitness makes it less objectionable, but parental discretion is advised. Ultimately, the decision rests on individual family values and the child’s maturity level.
A Broadway Experience at the Walter Kerr Theater
The Walter Kerr Theater, though small, provides an intimate and charming setting for this production. While front row mezzanine seats offer a great view, the slight obstruction of a bar might be a consideration. The theater’s unique features, such as the efficient restroom management during intermission, add to the overall positive experience.
alt: Detail of a wall mural inside the Walter Kerr Theater
Securing Tickets to the Show
With the show’s ongoing success, discount tickets are often available, making it accessible to a wider audience. Various resources, including dedicated Broadway discount ticket websites, can help theatergoers find affordable options.
A Must-See Musical Comedy
A Gentleman’s Guide to Love and Murder is a delightful and entertaining theatrical experience. The clever plot, witty dialogue, and brilliant performance by Jefferson Mays make it a must-see for fans of musical comedy. While some lyrical clarity may be sacrificed, the overall production is a triumph of creativity and humor.
alt: The D'Ysquith family insignia displayed prominently on the stage of A Gentleman's Guide to Murder.
A Final Verdict
From its ingenious staging and captivating love triangle to its memorable characters and witty humor, A Gentleman’s Guide to Love and Murder offers a truly unique and entertaining theatrical experience. While the musical numbers might not all be earworms, the overall production is a testament to the power of clever writing, brilliant acting, and innovative staging. If you’re seeking a night of laughter and intrigue, this Tony Award-winning musical is sure to delight.
