The double homicide of Abigail “Abby” Williams and Liberty “Libby” German in Delphi, Indiana, continues to captivate and horrify the nation. While Richard Allen currently stands accused, his defense team has introduced a shocking new theory: a white nationalist group practicing a form of Odinism is responsible for the girls’ deaths.
This bombshell allegation, presented in a 136-page document filed by defense attorneys Andrew Baldwin and Brad Rozzi, claims that Abby and Libby were ritualistically sacrificed by members of this extremist group. The defense argues that two separate Odinist groups, one local to Delphi and another from the Rushville area, were initially investigated but that this information was withheld from them. They further contend that ritualistic symbols found at the crime scene, including the positioning of Libby’s body, corroborate their theory. The filing contains graphic details, some of which may be disturbing to readers.
The defense posits that the girls were targeted because one of their parents was in an interracial relationship, a motive they believe aligns with the white nationalist ideology. They also outline 92 separate reasons why, in their view, a single individual could not have committed the murders. Among these is the alleged insufficient investigation of a potential suspect with ties to both the victims and Odinism, whose alibi, the defense argues, was not thoroughly vetted.
Central to the defense’s argument is the claim that the search warrant executed on Allen’s property was obtained fraudulently. They allege a detective lied to secure the warrant and have requested a Frank’s hearing to address this issue. If successful, any evidence obtained from the search would be inadmissible in court.
Furthermore, the defense has renewed their request for Allen’s transfer from the Westville Correctional Facility, citing threats to his safety from Odinist inmates and staff. They allege Allen reported these threats, which they claim corroborates their independent investigation into Odinist involvement, despite never having discussed their theory with him beforehand. They even claim to have observed correctional officers wearing “In Odin We Trust” patches.
This motion follows a July ruling by Special Judge Fran Gull denying a previous request to transfer Allen. At that time, the judge determined the evidence did not demonstrate Allen was being treated unfairly.
A makeshift memorial near the Monon High Bridge Trail in Delphi, Indiana, where the bodies of Liberty German and Abigail Williams were discovered.
The defense’s accusations raise numerous questions about the investigation and the potential involvement of extremist groups. The claim that crucial information was withheld from the defense, if proven, could have significant implications for the case. The alleged ritualistic nature of the murders adds another layer of complexity to an already perplexing and tragic story.
The request for a Frank’s hearing will be a pivotal moment in the proceedings. If the judge rules in favor of the defense, the prosecution’s case against Allen could be significantly weakened. The allegations regarding Allen’s safety in prison also raise serious concerns, regardless of the veracity of the Odinist theory.
The Delphi murders have been a source of ongoing grief and frustration for the community. The introduction of this new theory by the defense adds another twist to the ongoing search for justice and closure. While the focus remains on finding the truth and holding those responsible accountable, the path to justice in Delphi appears increasingly convoluted.
This complex case continues to unfold, leaving the public with more questions than answers. Will the defense’s claims hold up under scrutiny? Will the alleged evidence of Odinist involvement lead to new suspects? The legal battle ahead promises to be long and arduous, with the fate of Richard Allen and the pursuit of justice for Abby and Libby hanging in the balance.
