Uncovering the Real Cookie Jar: The Murder She Baked Filming Location

The Cookie Jar bakery exterior from Murder She Baked: A Chocolate Chip Cookie Mystery.alt: The charming exterior of the Cookie Jar bakery as seen in Murder She Baked: A Chocolate Chip Cookie Mystery, featuring white walls, pastel-colored chairs, and inviting double doors.

The world of Hallmark mysteries often sparks a desire to discover the real-life locations behind the charming fictional settings. This particular investigation focuses on the bakery from Murder She Baked: A Chocolate Chip Cookie Mystery, a location that has intrigued fans for years. While the series later moved to a more modern setting, the original bakery, known as the Cookie Jar in the first film, holds a special place in viewers’ hearts. This in-depth look reveals the real-life location, the changes made for filming, and some surprising connections to other Hallmark productions.

Exterior shot of the Blacksmith Bakery in Fort Langley, BC.alt: An exterior view of the Blacksmith Bakery, the real-life filming location for the Cookie Jar in Murder She Baked, showing its architectural details and location in Fort Langley.

Close-up of the Blacksmith Bakery's exterior details.alt: A detailed image of the Blacksmith Bakery’s exterior, highlighting the architectural features that link it to the Cookie Jar in Murder She Baked.

The search for the original Cookie Jar began online, but information was scarce. Numerous searches led to the newer bakery location used in later films. However, a closer examination of stills from the first movie, combined with a rewatch focused on visual clues, finally provided the necessary breakthrough.

The double doors of the Blacksmith Bakery.alt: A close-up of the distinct double doors of the Blacksmith Bakery, a key visual clue in identifying it as the Cookie Jar in Murder She Baked.

A screenshot from Murder She Baked showing the double doors of the Cookie Jar.alt: Screenshot from Murder She Baked showing the Cookie Jar’s double doors, matching the distinctive design of the Blacksmith Bakery doors.

The real-life bakery is the Blacksmith Bakery, located in the charming town of Fort Langley, British Columbia. Interestingly, the set designers made significant cosmetic changes to the interior, making it initially appear as though the bakery had been completely remodeled. However, key architectural details, such as the double doors, lighting, flooring, and structural elements, confirmed the match.

Benches across the street from the Blacksmith Bakery in Fort Langley.alt: Two benches situated across the street from the Blacksmith Bakery in Fort Langley, a prominent feature in a scene from Murder She Baked.

Screenshot from Murder She Baked showing Hannah looking out the window at the benches across the street.alt: A screenshot from Murder She Baked depicting Hannah looking out the Cookie Jar window at the benches across the street, a scene filmed at the Blacksmith Bakery in Fort Langley.

Fort Langley itself is a popular filming location for Hallmark productions. Its quaint streets and picturesque buildings have been featured in various movies and series, including Garage Sale Mystery and Cedar Cove. This charming town, filled with antique stores, specialty shops, and diverse dining options, provides the perfect backdrop for Hallmark’s signature style.

The interior seating area of the Blacksmith Bakery.alt: The interior seating area of the Blacksmith Bakery, demonstrating the layout and atmosphere of the real-life location used for the Cookie Jar in Murder She Baked.

Screenshot from Murder She Baked showing the interior of the Cookie Jar.alt: A screenshot from Murder She Baked showcasing the interior of the Cookie Jar, highlighting the similarities and differences compared to the real-life Blacksmith Bakery.

The counter area of the Blacksmith Bakery.alt: The counter area at the Blacksmith Bakery, revealing details of the real-life location compared to its onscreen portrayal as the Cookie Jar in Murder She Baked.

Screenshot from Murder She Baked showcasing the counter area of the Cookie Jar.alt: A screenshot from Murder She Baked displaying the counter area of the Cookie Jar, allowing comparison with the real-life counter at the Blacksmith Bakery.

The interior doors of the Blacksmith Bakery.alt: The interior doors of the Blacksmith Bakery, offering a glimpse into the layout and design of the actual location used for filming the Cookie Jar scenes in Murder She Baked.

Screenshot from Murder She Baked showing the interior doors of the Cookie Jar.alt: Screenshot from Murder She Baked featuring the interior doors of the Cookie Jar, providing a visual reference for comparing the film set to the actual Blacksmith Bakery.

The counter and display area in the Blacksmith Bakery.alt: The counter and display area inside the Blacksmith Bakery, showcasing the real-life details that were adapted for the Cookie Jar in Murder She Baked.

Screenshot from Murder She Baked focusing on the counter area of the Cookie Jar.alt: Screenshot from Murder She Baked highlighting the counter area inside the Cookie Jar, allowing viewers to compare it to the actual Blacksmith Bakery counter.

The building where the milk truck murder scene was filmed.alt: The building in Fort Langley used for filming the milk truck murder scene in Murder She Baked, identifiable by its distinctive awning.

A closer view of the milk truck murder scene location.alt: A detailed view of the area where the milk truck murder scene was filmed in Murder She Baked, showing the railing, lights, and wooden posts.

Screenshot from Murder She Baked showing the milk truck murder scene.alt: Screenshot from Murder She Baked depicting the milk truck murder scene, highlighting the visual elements that match the real-life location in Fort Langley.

The memorial marker in front of the Blacksmith Bakery.alt: The memorial marker placed in front of the Blacksmith Bakery in Fort Langley, commemorating the historical significance of the Reid Block.

The Espresso Pecan Brownie from the Blacksmith Bakery.alt: A delectable Espresso Pecan Brownie from the Blacksmith Bakery, a recommended treat for visitors to the real-life Cookie Jar location in Fort Langley.

The Blacksmith Bakery, steeped in history dating back to 1910, offers more than just its cinematic appeal. Owner Stephan Schigas named the bakery in tribute to the building’s past as the Blacksmith Shop & Garage owned by Charles Reid. This connection to the past adds another layer of charm to this already fascinating location. The Blacksmith Bakery offers a variety of treats, from coffee and baked goods to breakfast, sandwiches, and pizza. Located at 9190 Church Street, Suite 102 in Fort Langley, BC, it’s a must-visit for any Hallmark movie enthusiast or anyone looking for a delicious treat in a historically significant setting.