Jason Aldean’s “Try That in a Small Town” ignited a firestorm of controversy upon its release in May 2023. The song, intended to be a celebration of small-town values, quickly became a lightning rod for criticism, sparking debates about gun control, racial undertones, and the role of music in reflecting societal tensions. This article delves into the heart of the controversy, exploring the various perspectives surrounding the song and its impact on the cultural landscape.
Initially, Aldean anticipated some backlash, particularly regarding the lyrics about gun ownership: “Got a gun that my granddaddy gave me / They say one day they’re gonna round up / Well that s–t might fly in the city, good luck.” However, the controversy extended far beyond gun rights. The music video, filmed at the Maury County Courthouse, a site with a dark history involving a 1927 lynching, further fueled accusations of racism and dog whistling.
The Song’s Message and Intent
In his first interview discussing “Small Town” with American Songwriter, Aldean, alongside the songwriters Kelly Lovelace, Kurt Allison, Neil Thrasher, and Tully Kennedy, addressed the controversy. They maintained the song’s core message was about upholding positive values and condemning wrongdoing. Kennedy emphasized, “The song was all about positivity of, like, ‘We’re not gonna stand for that.’ It’s obvious things that are wrong… This song was not written, recorded or released with negative thoughts. It was all about trying to fix the things that we thought were messed up.”
Aldean, now a seasoned artist with nearly 30 No. 1 hits and 11 studio albums, felt the time was right to release a song that went beyond a catchy tune and addressed deeper issues. He viewed it as a statement, a departure from his usual radio-friendly hits. He recalled telling his record label, “Hey, we can give you guys another fastball down-the-middle radio candy song… Or we can give you something that actually says something, that actually means something.” He sought to create a song that carried weight and provoked reflection. He anticipated stirring the pot and hoped the song would challenge listeners to reassess their perspectives.
The Controversy Unfolds
Despite the songwriters’ stated intentions, many critics interpreted “Try That in a Small Town” differently. Some perceived the lyrics as promoting gun-based vigilante justice. Others, especially after the release of the music video, viewed the song as racially charged, with the courthouse backdrop serving as a symbolic reminder of a painful history of racial violence.
/cdn.vox-cdn.com/uploads/chorus_image/image/71347139/GettyImages_1241915228.0.jpg)
Aldean’s Response and the Broader Debate
Aldean vehemently denied any racist intent behind the song. He stated that the song was about community and standing up against criminal behavior. However, the controversy persisted, sparking a national conversation about the intersection of music, politics, and social issues. The debate spilled onto social media, with supporters and detractors engaging in heated exchanges. Some defended Aldean’s right to artistic expression, while others condemned the song as harmful and divisive.
The Impact on Aldean’s Career
Despite the controversy, “Try That in a Small Town” achieved commercial success, becoming Aldean’s 28th No. 1 hit and his first-ever chart-topper on the Billboard Hot 100. He celebrated the milestone with a party alongside the songwriters. The song also served as the lead single for his newest album, Highway Desperado, released in November 2023.
“Try That in a Small Town” in the Context of Controversial Country Music
“Try That in a Small Town” joined the ranks of other controversial country songs that have sparked debate and challenged societal norms. Country music has a long history of addressing sensitive topics, from social inequality to political dissent. Artists like Loretta Lynn, Tim McGraw, Merle Haggard, Tanya Tucker, and Carrie Underwood have all released songs that have generated controversy and pushed boundaries. “Try That in a Small Town” adds another chapter to this history, highlighting the ongoing tension between artistic expression and social responsibility.
Examining the Lyrics and Their Interpretations
The lyrics of “Try That in a Small Town” paint a picture of small-town life, emphasizing community values and a strong sense of justice. Lines like “car jacking an old lady at a red light,” “cussing out a cop,” “stomping on the flag,” and “lighting up the courthouse” depict actions that are seen as violations of this social order. The song suggests these actions would not be tolerated in a small town.
However, critics argue that these lyrics, combined with the music video’s imagery, create a threatening atmosphere, particularly for people of color. The courthouse setting, with its historical connection to racial injustice, is seen as particularly problematic. Critics also point to the line about owning a gun, interpreting it as a call to vigilante justice.
The Role of the Music Video
The music video for “Try That in a Small Town” significantly amplified the controversy surrounding the song. The decision to film at the Maury County Courthouse, a location with a history of racial violence, was viewed by many as insensitive and inflammatory. The video intersperses footage of Aldean performing with news clips depicting protests and social unrest. This juxtaposition further fueled the debate, with some arguing that the video demonizes social justice movements.
The Future of the Debate
The controversy surrounding “Try That in a Small Town” is unlikely to fade away quickly. The song has touched a nerve in American society, highlighting deep divisions and differing perspectives on issues of race, gun control, and the role of art in social commentary. As the debate continues, it is crucial to engage in thoughtful and respectful dialogue, acknowledging the complex emotions and perspectives surrounding the song and its impact.
FAQ
Q: What is the main controversy surrounding “Try That in a Small Town”?
A: The controversy stems from accusations of the song promoting vigilantism, containing racist undertones, and featuring a music video filmed at a historically sensitive location associated with racial violence.
Q: What was Jason Aldean’s response to the criticism?
A: Aldean denied any racist intent, stating the song celebrates small-town values and condemns criminal behavior. He also emphasized his right to artistic expression.
Q: How did the music video contribute to the controversy?
A: The video, filmed at the Maury County Courthouse, a site with a history of racial violence, intensified the accusations of racism and further polarized public opinion.
Q: What is the broader significance of this controversy?
A: The controversy highlights ongoing debates about the intersection of music, politics, and social issues, raising questions about artistic freedom, social responsibility, and the interpretation of artistic works.
We encourage you to share your thoughts and questions in the comments below. Let’s continue the conversation about this important and complex topic.
